In 1974, I was the Regional Editor of the third largest
newspaper in West Virginia. I had a responsible job, supervised a staff of eight
or 10 paid correspondents, worked long hours and traveled around nine counties
in the state in my own car (and on my own dime, as I recall).
I was not, in other words, a lazy slacker.
For my efforts, if memory serves, I was paid somewhere in the neighborhood of
$8,000 a year with zero health insurance benefits. I had a wife who didn’t work
and a two-year-old daughter and, in September of that year, my younger daughter
was born. My employer – out of the goodness of its heart – provided us with a
maternity benefit to help defray several hundred dollars in hospital costs.
They gave us $35.
It was so insulting I almost gave it back.
I believe we qualified for food stamps back then, as well as
free government cheese, but never applied for those programs out of a distorted
sense of pride. The Regional Editor of the third largest newspaper in the state
did not accept food stamps or blocks
of condensed Velveeta. We also did not enroll in Medicaid.
If we had, I would have been the kind of “able-bodied worker”
that Kellyanne Conway thinks should be excluded from the Medicaid program. On
Sunday, while discussing the Senate's proposal to replace the Affordable Care
Act, Conway said people who will lose Medicaid coverage under the Republican health
care plan should just go find jobs that provide health insurance.
Gee, I wish I had thought of that back in 1974. I never would
have accepted a job with the lowly Parkersburg
Sentinel when I could have demanded to be hired as Editor-in-Chief of The New York Times...or advisor to the president.
In the interest of full disclosure, I’m not sure I qualified
for Medicaid in 1974. I called the West Virginia Department of Health and Human
Resources but they don’t seem to know what the income limit was back then. When
I asked the question, I was told, “Good luck with that.” I had to email the
question to them and I’m still waiting for a response.
It doesn’t matter, though. The point is that millions of
Americans are receiving Medicaid benefits while working at jobs that do not
provide health insurance coverage. Many of them work very hard at the only
thing they are qualified for – or the only job they could get – and do not
deserve to be labeled as slackers by a public relations hack who reportedly is
paid $176,000 a year to lie to the media and make up “alternative facts.”
According to Conway, Medicaid was never designed for “healthy
people who could work.” Those people, she said, should take better jobs where “they'll
have employer-sponsored benefits like you and I do.” The absurdity of that statement makes it almost
impossible for a response, but here’s one anyway:
Jonathan Cohn points out in the Huffington Post that nearly
eight in 10 Medicaid recipients live in working families and a majority are
working themselves. Fifty-nine percent of them work either part- or full-time. The
problem is that they work as parking attendants and child care workers,
manicurists and dishwashers – in other words, low-paying jobs that typically
don't offer insurance. Take away their Medicaid and they won't be covered at
all.
First off, don’t we need people to do the jobs they
do? If not for them, who would park the cars and wash the dishes and babysit
our children? Who else is going to do that? You, Kellyanne?
And second, I would argue that even the “healthy, able-bodied”
adults to whom she refers sometimes get sick and require medical care that the
Emergency Room doesn’t provide, or maybe their wives have babies, or they want
contraception so they don’t have
babies, or they contract catastrophic illnesses and face death, or any of a
number of other reasons why they need Medicaid to survive.
But not to worry. When Donald Trump, his
children and his 400 closest billionaire friends get their massive tax break, I'm sure they'll create millions of new jobs with full benefits for all of the people who got kicked out of Medicaid. Either that, or they'll buy more summer
houses, private jets and yachts.
No comments:
Post a Comment